07Litigation Support & Appraisal

Independent property damage analysis for property insurance disputes.

Estimate review, appraisal services, and consulting-expert support for counsel on either side of a property insurance dispute.

Independence

Independent by design.

Roux & Crew’s opinions follow the building, the documentation, and the estimate, not the party that retains us. We accept engagements from policyholder counsel, carrier counsel, and appraisal panels.

Engagements are billed hourly, and our conclusions are not contingent on the outcome of a matter.

02Services

Four defined engagements.

Each engagement is scoped in writing before work begins, so counsel knows what is being reviewed and what the deliverable will be.

LS/01

Estimate Review & Case Evaluation

An early, defined-scope review of carrier and contractor estimates: scope completeness, quantities, Xactimate pricing and labor-model issues, and code and standards considerations. Written findings help counsel evaluate a claim before committing resources.

LS/02

Appraisal & Umpire Services

Serving as an appraiser, and on select matters as an umpire, under property insurance appraisal provisions. Independent evaluation of the amount of loss, supported by documentation, field conditions, and recognized estimating practice.

LS/03

Litigation Consulting

Consulting-expert support: document and estimate analysis, identifying gaps in opposing estimates and reports, preparing questions for depositions, and coordinating with engineers and other experts. Availability to serve as a testifying expert on scope, estimating, and restoration practice where appropriate.

LS/04

Site Inspection & Documentation

Field inspection with photo, drone, and 360 documentation that preserves conditions as evidence.

03Methodology

How the analysis is built.

The same method is applied whether the matter settles, goes to appraisal, or goes to trial.

M/01

Field inspection and documentation

Conditions are observed and recorded in person, not inferred from a file.

M/02

Scope from observed conditions

Observed damage is distinguished from concealed damage, and mitigation from reconstruction.

M/03

Quantities verified

Material quantities are measured and checked against the documented conditions.

M/04

Pricing and labor reviewed

Pricing and labor are reviewed against current Xactimate data.

M/05

Standards referenced where applicable

ANSI/IICRC S500 for water, S520 for mold, S700 for fire and smoke, and the Florida Building Code.

M/06

Written report

A written report states the basis for each opinion.

Credentials

Matt Roux, principal.

Work on a matter is performed and signed by the principal. Residential and commercial properties. Tampa Bay based, working across Florida and nationwide.

30+
Years of construction experience
12+
Years of insurance and restoration experience
$225M+
Catastrophe loss values
$75M+
Non-catastrophe loss values
Florida Licensed All-Lines Adjuster (0620), License No. G158884
Xactimate Level 3 Certified (current through April 2028)
Florida Licensed Mold Assessor (MRSA5594)
Florida Licensed Mold Remediation Contractor (MRSR5594)
FAA Part 107 UAS Remote Pilot
Deposition testimony as a designated expert on multiple occasions; no trial testimony to date.
04Engagement

How an engagement works.

01

Conflict check

We confirm there is no conflict before any documents are reviewed.

02

Document review and scope of engagement

Records are reviewed and the engagement is defined in writing.

03

Inspection and analysis

Field inspection, measurement, and estimate analysis.

04

Written findings

A report stating the basis for each opinion.

05

Ongoing support

Continued support through appraisal, mediation, or trial.

Intake

What to send us.

  • D/01Policy declarations
  • D/02Carrier estimate and correspondence
  • D/03Contractor or public adjuster estimates
  • D/04Photos
  • D/05Engineering or other expert reports
  • D/06Key dates and deadlines
Fees

Engagements are billed hourly. A current fee schedule is provided with our engagement letter.

FAQ

Common questions.

Yes. We accept engagements from policyholder counsel, carrier counsel, and appraisal panels. Our opinions follow the building, the documentation, and the estimate, not the party that retains us.

Next

Discuss a matter with the principal.

Discuss a Matter